Eldritch Guidance

Chapter 177 – Reality vs Senses

The interior of the Mystic Emporium was unnaturally still, the usual ambient sense of waiting suspended. Only the frantic, rhythmic sound of footsteps on the polished wooden floor broke the silence. John paced a tight, anxious circuit between a rack of silent brass astrolabes and a cabinet holding petrified seeds in glass vials, his movements sharp with a barely-contained panic.

Lunar, his companion, watches from the corner of the room. Its head swiveled with each pass John made, its eyes wide with canine concern. It let out a soft, questioning whine, and was ignored.

Abruptly, John broke from his path and strode to a large, ornate mirror that had manifested just that morning on the far wall—its frame was tarnished silver, etched with phases of a moon that didn’t match Lunar’s cycles. He leaned in, his nose almost touching the cold glass, his breath fogging a small circle.

His reflection stared back, pale and strained. For the fifth time that hour, he began a meticulous, desperate inspection. His fingers, trembling slightly, probed the skin around his right eye—the eye Onyx had… taken. He pulled at the lower lid, peering at the unblemished white and the clear, brown iris within. He pressed against the orbital bone, searching for a hidden tenderness, a hairline fracture, any proof of violation. He found nothing. The skin was smooth, unbroken. The eye moved normally, tracked his finger. It was, by every objective measure, perfectly fine.

He stepped back with a ragged exhale. The encounter with Onyx—the sudden, shocking pain, the feeling of something vital being removed, the sight of the old man holding a glistening orb that was his—had felt more real than the solid floor beneath his feet. It had the visceral, unforgettable texture of truth, not the vague wisps of a dream or a stress-induced hallucination.

And yet, the physical evidence was absent. It was a crime scene without a body, a scream with no echo. The dissonance was maddening. He wasn't just doubting a memory; he was doubting the fundamental reality of his own flesh.

His reflection showed the true cost. Dark, bruise-like smudges had formed under his eyes. His hair was disheveled from repeated runs of his hands through it. The calm, inscrutable mask of the shopkeeper was gone, stripped away to reveal the raw, vulnerable man beneath—a man haunted by an entity he couldn't understand and a trauma his body refused to corroborate.

He stared into his own weary eyes in the glass. This is how it starts, a cold voice whispered in his mind. The unraveling. First the memory, then the sanity.

Desperate to claw back some semblance of control, he forced the corners of his mouth upward into a smile. It was a ghastly, strained thing that didn’t touch his eyes—a grimace of bone and willpower that was meant to be soothing but felt like a betrayal. The reflection smiled back, a mockery of composure, a silent scream in a polished frame.

The forced, sickly smile in the mirror didn't bring calm. It opened a lock he’d sealed long ago.

It all came crashing back, not as memories, but as a sensory avalanche. The sterile, hostile quiet of his old home. The way his ex-wife’s voice would soften into syrup just before she’d reshape a truth he’d clung to. “You’re so tired, John. You’re confused. You know I’d never say that.” The slow, meticulous dismantling of his perceptions until the world itself felt like a funhouse mirror, every reflection a lie. The gaslighting had been an assault on his reality itself, making him question his own eyes, his own ears, the very evidence of his senses. He had been broken, his mind made a prison of doubt, and she had held the only key, using it to hurt him deeper, convincing him the bars were of his own making.

And now, here it was again. The same gut-deep terror. The same fracture between what he knew had happened and what the world insisted was true. Onyx, with his alien calm and impossible actions, ripping out his eye one moment and leaving it untouched the next—was it the same? A new, more profound manipulation? Had he escaped one prison of doubt only to be delivered into another, far more intricate one?

The thought didn’t just disturb him; it unmoored him. A wave of vertigo worse than any before hit him, followed by a violent, greasy lurch in his stomach. The phantom taste of copper and betrayal flooded his mouth.

He clapped a hand over his lips, his eyes wide with a panic that had nothing to do with magic and everything to do with a past he thought he’d buried. He stumbled away from the mirror, weaving past shelves of silent artifacts, and burst into the small bathroom at the back of the Emporium. He barely made it, falling to his knees and heaving his head over the porcelain bowl.

John: “Blaaaugh!” The retch was raw and violent, expelling his lunch and decade of suppressed terror and helplessness.

He clung to the cool sides of the toilet, trembling, sweat beading on his forehead as dry heaves wracked his body long after there was nothing left to give.

He knelt there on the cold tiles for what felt like an age—fifteen minutes of shaky breaths and the sour, acrid smell of his own fear. Each passing second was a battle against the rising tide of nausea, a fight to keep the panic from pulling him completely under. Slowly, agonizingly, the tremors subsided. The urgent knot in his gut loosened from a clenched fist to a dull, persistent ache.

With a strength that felt borrowed, he pushed himself up, his legs unsteady. He avoided the mirror above the sink, instead leaning his forehead against the cool, painted wall. The crisis had passed, for now. But the deeper sickness—the chilling fear that Onyx was simply a more advanced version of his old tormentor remained.

John remained slumped against the bathroom wall, the chill of the tiles seeping through his clothes. He was painfully aware of what he must look like: pale, sweating, eyes red-rimmed from strain and the ghost of vomit on his breath. The composed, enigmatic shopkeeper was gone, replaced by a raw nerve of a man trembling on the edge of a past he’d thought he’d escaped.

A desperate, silent plea formed in his mind. Please, no customers. Not now. The thought of the bell above the Emporium door chiming, of having to force his face into that neutral mask, to speak and offer help or advice while his own reality was crumbling… it was unthinkable. He needed silence. He needed the oppressive, familiar quiet of the shop to be just that—quiet.

More than that, he needed his friends to stay away. Not out of a lack of care, but because of it. He couldn’t bear for them to see him looking so utterly shattered. He needed an hour, a day, just a little space to try and glue the pieces of himself back into some semblance of order.

The real work, he knew, wasn’t about washing his face or changing his clothes. It was the internal battle. He had to find a way to ground himself, to anchor his mind in the now of this strange world, not the then of his old torment. The gaslighting had taught him a horrific lesson: that reality could be stolen from you, piece by piece, by someone you trusted. Onyx’s actions felt like a cosmic echo of that violation, but he couldn’t let the past poison his perception of the present. He couldn’t spiral into the old paranoia, where every unexplained event became proof of a grand, malicious deception. He had to find proof, not of Onyx’s intentions, but of his own sanity. He had to trust the solidity of the wooden floor, the dust motes in a sunbeam, the weight of an object in his hand—the mundane, tangible truths of the world he lived in.

He couldn’t afford to lose himself to delusion again. Not here. He had to be the steady point, even if he had to fake it until the storm inside passed. Taking a final, shuddering breath, he pushed himself upright, facing his haunted reflection in the bathroom mirror not with a smile, but with a weary, determined resolve. The first step was to clean himself up. The rest would have to come one agonizing, conscious thought at a time.

♦♦♦♦♦

Fenny, a slender figure shrouded by the hood of a leather jacket, moved with a quiet grace along Eld Street.

The magical effect woven into the hood’s fabric shimmered faintly, a subtle distortion field that obscured the skeletal vulpine features beneath, presenting only a blurred, shadowed impression of a face to the casual observer.

It was a necessary precaution; even in a city like Graheel, where mutants were a grudging part of the landscape, a walking fox skeleton tended to cause disruptions he didn’t want to deal with. His gloved hands were tucked into his pockets, the black leather worn smooth at the fingertips.

The mid-afternoon bustle of the street flowed around him, a river of mundane life he observed from its banks. He passed a cluster of women animatedly debating the merits of the latest imported lace from the neighboring States, their voices bright and fleeting as birdsong. Further on, a group of men leaned against a lamppost, grumbling with the hollow bravado of being freshly bankrupt, their stories of last night’s dice game at the Silver Serpent casino painting a familiar picture of local color.

The sun cast long, warm shadows that stretched across the cobblestones, and the air was a layers of scents: the rich, yeasty promise of baking bread from Lindsey’s Bakery, the sharp, astringent tang of herbs and preservatives wafting from The Bubbling Beaker, and beneath it all, the ever-present damp-stone smell of the city itself. Everything was, to all outward senses, perfectly normal.

Eventually, Fenny’s silent steps brought him to a specific, unremarkable, stretch of the street. He knew the count of cobblestones here, the particular crack in the mortar three feet up. It was bracketed by the warm, golden-lit windows of the bakery on one side and the dark green, bottle-filled panes of the alchemy shop on the other. Between them was a blank expanse of aged brick and mortar, about eight feet wide. To anyone else, it was just a wall.

He stopped. A faint tension, imperceptible to anyone else, tightened the muscles across his shoulders and back. The Mystic Emporium’s presence was absent. There was only silence, both audible and metaphysical.

Slowly, he extended a gloved hand and placed it flat against the cool brickwork. He pressed into it, his fingers splaying to feel the rough, unyielding texture. It was utterly solid, chillingly real. He traced the grout lines with a fingertip, feeling the gritty, mundane reality of cured mortar and centuries-old clay. He leaned in, as if listening, but heard only the distant echo of street noise and the pulse of his own concern.

Fenny: “What’s going on?” he murmured. It wasn’t a question for the wall, but for the world that had decided to hide a door.

Confusion settled in his mind. This was the place. The coordinates were etched into his memory not as a street number, but as a feeling—a subtle wrongness in the air, a perceptual fold you had to know how to step through. The Mystic Emporium had never obeyed common rules of location. It wasn't hidden by magic in the traditional sense; it was hidden by some greater means. For Fenny, it had always been about a specific angle of approach, a momentary defocusing of the eyes. The door would then appear along with some display windows.

Now, it wasn't working. He walked the block again, his pace slowing. He approached from the north, eyes averted until the last second. Nothing. He circled, came from the south, his gaze fixed on a point above the bakery’s sign before snapping down. Still nothing but bare brick. He tried the old trick of not looking at all, walking past with his mind purposefully blank, trusting his peripheral vision to catch the shift. It didn’t.

A cold knot of unease formed in his chest. If he hadn’t been a regular visitor for years, hadn’t had conversation with its enigmatic proprietor, hadn’t felt the tangible weight of the strange treats John sometimes provided… he might have begun to doubt his own memory. He might have wondered if the Emporium, with its impossible shelves and its keeper who seemed to understand the shape of wounds no one else could see, had been an elaborate, prolonged hallucination.

Fenny: “Can the Mystic Emporium… move?” he asked the empty air, his voice a low rasp barely audible over the street’s murmur. “Or is the entrance just… closed?”

He wasn’t truly expecting an answer from the brickwork, but voicing the questions helped his mind grapple with the impossibility. He began a more systematic examination, running his gloved fingers over every seam and irregularity in the wall. He pressed against stones, seeking a hidden latch or a pressure point. To an outside observer, it was the behavior of a confused eccentric.

A young child, being led by a parent, paused and pointed a chubby finger.

Child: “Mama, why is that man talking to the wall?”

The parent, following the child’s gaze, took in Fenny’s shrouded figure and his intense, one-sided conversation with the masonry. A flicker of unease—the ingrained city-dweller’s wariness of the unpredictable—crossed their face.

Mother: “Don’t stare, dear. Come along.” They tightened their grip and quickly steered the child away, casting a final, wary glance over their shoulder. Fenny didn’t notice; his world had narrowed to the eight-foot span of inexplicable brick.

His investigation yielded nothing but grit on his gloves. He stepped back, crossing his arms in a gesture of deep, frustrated thought.

Fenny: “I just wanted to let John know we have to cancel game night. Cid’s tied up with… whatever Scarlett has him working on now.” A faint, almost nostalgic ache touched him—those rare, strange evenings of skewed normalcy and fun in the back of the shop were something he hadn’t realized he clung to so tightly. “But I guess if I can’t even find John, game night is definitely off.”

His mind, conditioned to think in workarounds, presented a dangerous possibility.

Fenny: “I wonder… could I use the Ways Between? Slip through a crack in reality and just… step into the shop from the inside out?” He immediately dismissed it with a slight shake of his head, the hood swaying. “No. Terrible idea. That’s a good way to get lost, or worse. Places like this… they’re like Allara’s Dollhouse. They have their own rules for entry, and if the door isn’t offered, you don’t get in.”

He fell silent again, simply staring at the blank wall as if his gaze could burn through the illusion. The mundane sounds of the street—a burst of laughter from the bar down the way—felt suddenly loud and intrusive, emphasizing the profound emptiness from where the Emporium should be.

A quiet worry, colder and more persistent than confusion, finally settled in his ribcage.

Fenny: “I hope everything is okay,” he murmured, the words almost lost. “I hope John is… fine.” The unspoken alternative hung in the air. This didn’t feel like a simple case of a shopkeeper taking a day off. This felt…diffrent. “And I really hope this isn’t a sign that something bad is coming.”

With a final, long look that held more concern than his skeletal face could ever show, Fenny turned. He moved back down Eld Street, his pace slower now, weighed down by unease. He glanced back three times, each look a silent question aimed at the ordinary wall. The brickwork offered no answers. Finally, he rounded a corner, his cloaked figure melting into the lengthening shadows of the afternoon, leaving the space where a mystery once lived feeling emptier than ever before.

Visit and read more novel to help us update chapter quickly. Thank you so much!

Report chapter

Use arrow keys (or A / D) to PREV/NEXT chapter