I Was Marked By The System's Arbiter

Chapter 137: Chapter 137: Who Will You Give?

Bai Wuyin.

The wood had barely finished breathing out its last curl of shaving before the room went the particular kind of silent that wasn’t silence at all — it was thirty-one people not exhaling, all at once, and Lin Yue’s own pulse loud enough in his ears to fill the gap where sound should have been.

Nobody moved.

That was the part that would stay with him longer than the carving itself, later, when he had the luxury of picking the moment apart in pieces — that for two, maybe three full seconds, none of them so much as flinched. Not Su Qing, whose hand was still half-raised from the pages she’d been holding a moment ago. Not Shen Rui, caught mid-breath with his jaw locked. Not He Yuan, whose eyes had gone from the desk to Bai Wuyin and stayed there, wide and disbelieving, as if repetition might change what they’d just watched carved into fifty-year-old grain.

Bai Wuyin didn’t move either.

That was what Lin Yue noticed first, before anything else — before his own instincts caught up with the rest of him and told him what to do with his body. Bai Wuyin’s face hadn’t changed. The frightened crease between his brows, the small hunch of his shoulders, the wide-eyed stillness he’d worn since the moment they crossed the threshold into this room — none of it moved. It should have looked like nothing. It should have looked, to anyone who hadn’t spent months learning the difference, exactly like it always did.

It didn’t.

Lin Yue had watched Bai Wuyin perform fear a hundred times by now. He knew the shape of it, the practiced economy of it — a boy who’d learned early that looking frightened kept adults from asking harder questions, and who wielded that look now the way other players wielded a blade. He knew what performed fear looked like on Bai Wuyin’s face.

This wasn’t that.

The crease was the same. The wide eyes were the same. But underneath it, in the half-inch of difference Lin Yue had spent an entire instance learning to read, something had come loose. The boy wasn’t holding still because he’d chosen to. He was holding still because, for one unguarded second, he genuinely didn’t know what his body was supposed to do next.

"That’s—" Lu Fan’s voice cracked halfway through the word, and he had to start over. "That’s his name. That’s actually his—"

"I can read," Shen Rui said, low, already moving. His hand came up toward Bai Wuyin’s shoulder, instinctive, the same reflex that had made him reach for Ye Xian back at the door-frame ward, the reflex of a man who protected people before he’d finished deciding whether protection was the right response. "Wuyin. Wuyin, look at me—"

"The academy’s chosen him." He Yuan’s voice had gone thin and fast, the words tumbling out ahead of thought. "That’s what this means, isn’t it? That’s what the desk does. It picks a name and then—"

"We don’t know that." Su Qing’s voice cut through his, sharp enough to actually land. "We don’t know that’s what it means."

"What else would it mean?" Lu Fan’s hands had curled into fists at his sides, his gaze darting between the desk and Bai Wuyin like he expected the floor to open at any second. "It’s the empty desk. The Rule says never sit at it — we all know what that Rule is protecting against. It’s decided. It picked him."

"We should get him out." He Yuan again, already half-turning toward the door, toward the ordinary corridor and the ordinary night beyond a room that had stopped being ordinary the moment they’d stepped through it. "Right now, before it—"

"Before it what?" Su Qing’s voice hadn’t risen, but it had gone hard in a way that made even He Yuan stop mid-turn. "Before it does what, exactly? Look at him. Look at the desk. Has anything happened? Has there been a sound, a pull, a single thing move that we didn’t move ourselves?"

Nobody answered that, because nobody could.

"Someone should break it," Lu Fan said, and there was real desperation under the suggestion now, the kind that reached for anything solid to do with its hands. "The desk. If we destroy it—"

"You don’t know what that does either," Su Qing said. "None of us do. We are not making a decision this large off of panic."

It was, Lin Yue thought distantly, exactly the kind of clear-headedness he’d have expected from her under different circumstances — and it would have worked, too, would have held the room another few seconds longer, if he hadn’t already stopped listening to the argument entirely.

He didn’t think in those terms; that was a habit of memory he couldn’t place the origin of and didn’t have time to examine now. He was thinking about the bookshelf. About dozens of hands extended toward an empty seat, patient and endless, and about Bai Wuyin’s small body a half-step from crossing whatever line separated watching from belonging. He was thinking about the desks arranged, in aerial view, into the shape of a sentence none of them had understood until it was almost too late to matter.

He didn’t remember deciding to move.

By the time the thought fully assembled itself, he was already there — already standing between Bai Wuyin and the desk at the back of the room, angled so that anything reaching toward the boy would have to go through him first. He hadn’t announced it. He hadn’t asked permission, hadn’t waited for the group’s fractured argument to resolve into a plan. His body had simply arrived at the only answer that made sense to it, faster than the rest of him could weigh whether it was the correct one.

Bai Wuyin’s breath caught behind him. Lin Yue heard it — a small, sharp sound, nothing like the boy’s usual flat composure, gone almost as soon as it happened.

"Lin Yue—" Su Qing started.

"Don’t." He didn’t turn around. His eyes were on the desk, on the fresh dark grooves of the name still settling into the wood, still faintly wet-looking in a way carved wood had no business being. "Nobody touches him. Nobody moves him. Not until we understand what actually happened here."

"And if it’s already decided?" Shen Rui’s voice, tight.

"Then it can decide again," Lin Yue said. "Somewhere I’m standing in the way."

It wasn’t bravado. He was aware, distantly, that it might have sounded like it — the kind of line a hero said in the stories Bai Wuyin’s sketchbook sometimes seemed to be drawing toward, without either of them ever saying so out loud. But there was nothing dramatic in how he meant it. It was arithmetic. Bai Wuyin behind him, the desk in front of him, and only one acceptable order for those two facts to remain in.

The mark on his arm — the one the sealed classroom had left in him the night he’d pulled Bai Wuyin out from under all those reaching hands — chose that exact moment to remind him it existed.

It didn’t hurt, not exactly. It was closer to pressure, a tightening low under the skin like something recognizing its own reflection across the room and leaning toward it. He kept his face still. He’d had practice keeping his face still around this particular sensation.

The desk noticed.

He watched it happen — watched the carved letters of Bai Wuyin’s name deepen, the grooves biting a fraction darker into the grain, as though the room had felt his mark answer and decided the reaction was worth rewarding.

"It’s getting stronger," Su Qing said, very quietly. She hadn’t moved, but her eyes had gone to Lin Yue’s forearm, to wherever under his sleeve the mark sat. "Whatever that is — it’s reacting to you."

"I know," Lin Yue said.

"That’s not comforting."

"I wasn’t trying to be comforting. I was trying to be accurate."

Behind him, so low it was barely more than breath, Bai Wuyin said, "You shouldn’t have done that."

"Probably not," Lin Yue agreed, without turning. "Stand still anyway."

There was a beat where nobody spoke, where the argument that had been threatening to fracture the group entirely simply ran out of momentum against the fact of Lin Yue standing there, unmoved, refusing to be argued out of the space he’d put himself in. Lu Fan’s fists slowly loosened. He Yuan’s half-turn toward the door reversed itself, uncertain.

"Okay," Su Qing said, into the quiet. Her voice had steadied, deliberately, the way it always did when she needed the rest of them to steady with her. "Okay. Nobody’s dragging anyone anywhere. Nobody’s breaking anything. We look first. We think first." Her eyes went to the desk, to the name, careful and clinical even with the fear still audible underneath the control. "Because I don’t think it’s finished."

She was right.

The name held for one more second — long enough that Lin Yue let himself believe, briefly, stupidly, that it might simply stay that way, a wound already dealt that they could work around rather than a process still unfolding. Then the first letter began to fade.

Not scratched out. Not erased by any visible hand. It simply thinned, the dark grooves shallowing back toward bare wood the way a bruise shallowed back toward skin, until the character was gone entirely and the space where it had been sat blank, waiting.

"It’s changing," He Yuan said, unnecessary and urgent all at once.

A new shape began pressing itself into the grain where the old one had faded — the same slow, deliberate carving they’d watched complete Bai Wuyin’s name, except faster now, hungrier, like the room had learned the rhythm of the trick and no longer needed to be patient with it.

Lin.

Yue.

For one full second, Lin Yue looked at his own name cut into the surface of a desk that had waited fifty years to write something on it, and felt nothing so much as a strange, distant curiosity — the same flat interest he’d have given to a math problem that had just produced an answer he half-expected.

Then it changed again.

Su Qing.

Then, faster:

Shen Rui.

Lu Fan.

He Yuan.

Ye Xian.

The names came quicker each time, the carving losing whatever careful patience it had shown for Bai Wuyin, until the letters were barely resolving into shape before dissolving again, one after another, cycling through all seven of them in a rhythm too fast to be anything but frantic. The wood itself seemed to strain with it — Lin Yue could hear it, faintly, a dry creaking protest each time a fresh name tried to bite deeper than the last one had gone.

"It’s not choosing him," Su Qing said, and there was something almost like relief threading under the horror in her voice, thin and disbelieving. "Look — it’s not stopping on anyone. It’s just—"

"Cycling," Lin Yue finished. He watched his own name flash past a second time, and then a third, faster now, the carving barely completing two strokes before losing patience and starting over on someone else. "It doesn’t know who to pick."

"Or it isn’t picking at all," Bai Wuyin said, from just behind his shoulder. His voice had gone flat again — not the frightened flatness he wore for the group, but the other one, the quiet, precise register that only came out when it was just the two of them, and there was no one left to perform for. Except this time it wasn’t quite steady. There was a thread running under it that hadn’t been there before, thin and taut. "It’s not selecting a victim. It’s asking a question and getting seven different answers at once."

Lin Yue turned his head, just slightly, enough to catch the edge of Bai Wuyin’s face without taking his eyes fully off the desk. "What question?"

Bai Wuyin didn’t answer right away.

Above them, the ghost students had gone still again — not the frozen stillness from before, but something more attentive, more waiting. The scratch of thirty-one pencils had stopped entirely. When Lin Yue risked a glance sideways, he found row after row of bowed heads no longer bowed, faces angled instead toward the back of the room, toward the desk, toward all of them, with an intensity that hadn’t been there a minute ago.

If they start actually looking — if the direction turns into attention — that’s when it stops being safe to be this close to them.

Bai Wuyin’s own warning, spoken barely twenty minutes ago, came home to roost.

"They’re watching," Lin Yue said quietly.

"I know." Bai Wuyin’s voice had gone tighter still. "I told you what that meant."

The desk gave one final, groaning creak — and then, all at once, every name it had cycled through vanished, and the carving settled back into a single shape, dark and complete and unmistakable.

Bai Wuyin.

"There." Lu Fan’s voice cracked with something close to vindication, close to panic. "There, see — it went through everyone, and it came back to him. That’s not random. That’s a decision."

"It’s not," said a voice from outside the room.

Every head in the group turned at once.

The voice hadn’t come through the door so much as around it — muffled the way sound was muffled by distance and thick material, and yet perfectly clear at the same time, each word landing with none of its edges softened despite whatever lay between the speaker and the sealed room. It was a contradiction Lin Yue’s mind flagged and set aside without dwelling on, because there wasn’t time to dwell on it, because he already knew, before anyone said the name aloud, exactly whose voice it was.

"Zhou Mu?" Su Qing said, half question, half disbelief.

"I’m here." The voice was steady, unhurried, carrying the same unfailing courtesy it always did — the class president’s voice, the voice of a boy who was always early and always last to leave and who, as far as any of them had ever been able to determine, had never once been seen crossing a threshold to get anywhere. "I can’t come in. I won’t pretend that isn’t a limitation. But I can hear you, and I think — I think you need to hear this before any of you decide what that desk means."

"Then talk," Shen Rui said, low and urgent, eyes still fixed on the door as though he might be able to will it into showing them the boy on the other side of it.

There was a pause — not hesitation, exactly, more like someone choosing the shape of a sentence with care before letting it out.

"It isn’t claiming him," Zhou Mu said. "The desk. It’s not choosing Bai Wuyin. It never chose Ning Yue, or Tang Li, or Mo Jun, or Gao Lin, or Xin Yu, either — not the way you’re all afraid it did."

"Then what is it doing?" He Yuan’s voice had an edge of something close to desperate anger now, the anger of a man who’d already lost someone to this school and didn’t have patience left for riddles about it. "Because it wrote his name. It’s still writing his name. If it’s not choosing him, what exactly do you call that?"

"I call it showing you," Zhou Mu said, "what you’re afraid to lose."

The words landed into a silence so complete that Lin Yue could hear the faint, papery rustle of thirty-one exam sheets shifting at once, though nothing in the room had moved to cause it.

"That’s the last thing the school has left to feed on," Zhou Mu continued, quieter now, almost gentle. "It used to feed on memory. On names, on lessons, on the small ordinary details of who a person was before it forgot how to let anyone go. It doesn’t have that anymore — not the way it did. Most of what it could take, it’s already taken. What’s left is thinner. Harder to reach." A pause. "Fear is easier. Fear it can still find. And nothing feeds it faster than the fear of losing someone you’ve already decided matters."

"So it read the room," Su Qing said slowly, working through it out loud the way she did when a shape was still assembling itself under her hands. "It read all of us. It watched who moved first when the name appeared. It watched—" her eyes flicked, briefly, unmistakably, to Lin Yue, standing exactly where he’d put himself between Bai Wuyin and the desk "—who put themselves in the way."

"It didn’t have to watch very hard," Zhou Mu said, and there was something in his voice that might, in a boy less carefully composed, have been called sympathy. "You made it very easy to see."

Lin Yue felt something settle in his chest, cold and clean, the particular clarity that came whenever a piece of the instance finally clicked into a shape he could actually use.

"So the desk isn’t dangerous on its own," he said.

"No," Zhou Mu agreed. "It’s a mirror. A very old, very patient mirror, built by a school that never understood the difference between remembering someone and owning them. If you fear losing a person, the school reads that as proof they belong to it — proof there’s something worth taking. That’s all the carving has ever been. Not a sentence. Not a claim." A beat. "An invitation for you to hand it one."

"Then we don’t," Lin Yue said.

It came out simply, the way most of his conclusions did once he’d finished assembling them — not a declaration, just the plain shape of the only answer that made any sense once you’d seen the mechanism underneath the horror.

"Lin Yue," Su Qing said carefully, "if this is wrong—"

"It’s not wrong." He looked at the desk, at Bai Wuyin’s name still sitting dark and complete in the wood, and felt no urge at all to flinch from it now that he understood what it actually was. "We’ve been treating this like an execution. It’s a test. And it only works if we give it what it wants."

"Which is?" Lu Fan’s voice, still thin, still frightened, but listening now instead of arguing.

"A name," Lin Yue said. "One name. Someone we’re willing to let it think is expendable enough to hand over."

Behind him, so quiet only he could have caught it, Bai Wuyin’s breath went ragged for just a moment — one single, unguarded hitch of air that had nothing performed about it at all.

Lin Yue didn’t turn to look at him yet. There would be time for that. Right now there was a room full of thirty-one attentive faces and a group of frightened people who needed to hear the rest of it before the moment slipped away from them.

"So we don’t give it one," he said, louder now, for the whole room. "We refuse the premise. All of us. Together."

"That’s it?" He Yuan said, disbelieving. "We just — say no, and it lets go?"

"I don’t know if it’s that simple," Lin Yue admitted. "But I know what happens if we don’t try. It cycles through us until it finds whoever’s fear is loudest, and then it stops pretending to ask." His eyes went, briefly, to the desk. "It already showed us that it can write any of our names. That was the warning, not the threat."

There was a silence while that settled, while each of them, in their own way, weighed the shape of what he was asking.

"I’m not choosing anyone," Su Qing said first, quiet but absolute. "I won’t pretend I have a name to give it. I don’t."

"Neither am I." Shen Rui’s jaw was tight, but his voice didn’t waver. "We didn’t come this far to hand this place a person like a homework assignment."

"Nobody’s staying behind," He Yuan said, and there was real conviction under the words now, something that had been building since Ning Yue’s death and had finally found somewhere useful to point itself. "Not one more of us. Not like this."

Lu Fan exhaled, long and unsteady, his eyes going once, briefly, to the empty air where Tang Li and Xin Yu should have been standing if the instance had been even slightly kinder to any of them. "I’ve already lost people I couldn’t save," he said. "I’m not going to be the one who decides who’s next. I refuse."

Ye Xian, who had been quiet through most of the argument, standing a little apart the way he always did, finally spoke — light, almost amused, though there was something more careful underneath it than his usual detachment allowed. "For what it’s worth," he said, "I’ve never much cared for negotiating with furniture. Seems beneath both of us."

It shouldn’t have helped. It was a strange, glib thing to say in a room full of ghosts and grief. But something in the group’s collective posture loosened, just slightly, at the sound of it — the tiny, necessary release of tension that came from being reminded, even briefly, that they were still capable of something other than fear.

Bai Wuyin hadn’t spoken.

Lin Yue turned, finally, to look at him properly.

The frightened performance was still sitting on the boy’s face — the wide eyes, the small hunched posture, all of it present and correct for anyone else in the room to see. But close up, close enough that only Lin Yue was meant to catch it, something underneath had come apart in a way Lin Yue had genuinely never seen before. Not fear performed for an audience. Fear with nowhere left to go.

"You don’t have to say anything," Lin Yue said, low, just for him.

"I know." Bai Wuyin’s voice was barely a whisper, and it shook — actually shook, in a way his voice never did, not even in the sealed room with dozens of hands reaching for him. "I’ve watched other people die. Ning Yue. Tang Li. Mo Jun. Gao Lin. Xin Yu. I watched all of it, and I could still think. I could still be useful." He swallowed. "I looked at my own name on that desk, and I couldn’t think of anything at all."

Lin Yue didn’t answer right away. He let the admission sit, because it deserved to sit. After all, a boy who’d spent his whole life insisting no one was coming for him had just said, in the plainest terms he probably knew how to manage, that something had finally cracked the wall he’d built around exactly that belief.

"I thought I could be afraid without it mattering," Bai Wuyin said. "I was wrong."

"Then don’t think about losing anyone," Lin Yue said.

Bai Wuyin looked up at him, something raw and unguarded flickering across his mismatched eyes before the performance had a chance to smooth it back over.

"Think about what the room is asking us to do instead," Lin Yue went on, steady, deliberate, converting the moment back into something he knew how to hold. "It wants a name. That’s all it’s ever wanted. So we don’t give it one. That’s not comfort. That’s strategy. Stay with the strategy."

It wasn’t the kind of thing that fixed anything. Lin Yue was aware of that, distantly, the same way he was aware his own mark was still faintly warm under his sleeve. But he watched something in Bai Wuyin’s shoulders settle, fractionally, at having somewhere concrete to put the fear instead of just carrying it raw.

"Okay," Bai Wuyin said, so quiet it barely qualified as sound at all.

Lin Yue turned back to the desk.

The carving hadn’t waited politely for them to finish. As he watched, a hairline crack traced itself across the wood’s surface, thin and dry, running straight through the center of Bai Wuyin’s carved name. The letters themselves began to tremble — not fade this time, not cycle to some other name, but shake, faintly, like something under the surface was straining against a decision it didn’t like.

New characters began pressing themselves into the grain, rough and fast, gouged rather than carved, as though patience itself had run out.

WHO WILL YOU GIVE?

The question sat there, stark and demanding, and around them the exam papers on thirty-one desks began, all at once, to fill with the same four words, over and over, in handwriting too even to belong to thirty-one separate hands.

WHO WILL YOU GIVE?

WHO WILL YOU GIVE?

WHO WILL YOU GIVE?

The lights along the side wall flickered, once, in time with the scratch of pencils suddenly moving again, fast and frantic. Somewhere above them a fixture buzzed and dimmed and came back too bright.

Lin Yue looked at the question, at the room straining to make good on the seventy years of patience it had spent waiting for exactly this moment, and felt no fear at all — only the same cold, clean certainty he’d felt the instant his body had decided, without asking him, to step in front of Bai Wuyin.

"No one," he said.

The room didn’t answer.

"You’ve been waiting fifty years for someone to be afraid enough to give you a name," Lin Yue said, and his voice didn’t rise, didn’t need to — it carried anyway, flat and absolute, into every corner of a room built to swallow far louder things than this. "You’re not getting one. Not tonight. Not from any of us."

The pencils scratched faster. The crack down the center of the desk widened, a slow dry splinter working its way toward the edges of the wood.

Lin Yue looked at it, unmoved, and said the only thing left worth saying.

"Then it’s going to starve."

Visit and read more novel to help us update chapter quickly. Thank you so much!